Blog Comments as Social Currency

by Alan Belniak on August 31, 2010 · View Comments

in Social Media

currency

When I peruse blogs every day, I find a lot of stuff I like, some stuff I don’t like, and a little bit that I really like.  Like enough to warrant a comment, anyway.  But I don’t always comment.  I read through the comments first, and see if someone already said what I am planning on saying.  If so, I try to think of a different angle.  I try very hard to not simply say, “Great post!”.

What value does “Great post!” add?

None.  It gives the blog author a 0.1 second hit of euphoria, but that’s about it.  Blogs should be treated like conversations (despite what Mitch Joel has to say).  Let’s use the standard cocktail party analogy again (see item 8), because it works so well.

Imagine you’re at a cocktail party, in a circle of seven or so other people.  You have the floor, and are closing up a salient, original point on a current event.  You finish, take a sip of your drink, and someone in the circle says, “Great point.”  Then a pause, silence, and someone next to you says, “Great point.”  More silence, two seconds pass, a third “Great point.”

This isn’t a conversation.  It’s barely even dialogue.

Instead, someone else in the circle jumps off your point and starts up another, related conversation.  Partway through, she references something you said 60 seconds prior, thus tying the two thoughts together.  How much more interesting and engaging is her point, in addition to the total conversation?

The (new?) social currency among bloggers and readers these days isn’t so much “great post”, but rather heading on over to what they have to say and seeing if you can add value to one of their conversations on their site, if applicable. n That’s far more valuable (and euphoric) than “Great post!”, don’t you agree?  After all, isn’t that what this is all about?


Thanks to Tamsen McMahon {http://twitter.com/tamadear}, who inspired this post.

image courtesy of http://www.flickr.com/photos/bradipo/1435739708/



If you like what you’re reading here, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or signing up via e-mail (upper right corner) to be alerted when more new posts are added.

Scridb filter

{ 5 comments }

empty podium - source: http://www.flickr.com/photos/evrtstudio/
Much has been said about gaining that critical element of support from executives on your social media plan, initiative, or campaign.  I believe (and espouse this), as do others.  Read any current social media blogger theses days (including yours truly), or just do a generic Google search on ‘executive buy in social media‘.  Surely this is an important step, because it gives the initative some credence, lets others know there’s a reason they should participate, too, and that the idea has been well-thought-out.

But what if your social media plan, initiative, or campaign doesn’t have senior-management buy-in?

What do you do?

  • Do you stop right there, knowing or hunching that it won’t go anywhere?
    • If so, then what?
  • Do you forge ahead, hoping to gain momentum along the way, and hope for a mid-campaign meeting where you can change the tide?
  • Or do you forge ahead, skip the mid-campaign meeting anyway, and just forget about that buy-in all together?
    • What are your responses to the detractors in each case?
  • What if your entire job is social media, and it’s not just a plan, initiative, or campaign?
    • As a pre-emptive reply, I’m not saying this is necessarily the case where I work at the moment – I’m merely raising it because I thought abut it today.

Please take 60 seconds and drop a comment – I’m really curious to see how we all handle this stuff.

image courtesey of http://www.flickr.com/photos/evrtstudio/



If you like what you’re reading here, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or signing up via e-mail (upper right corner) to be alerted when more new posts are added.


Scridb filter

{ 8 comments }

Why Your Twitter Follower Count Matters / Why Your Twitter Follower Count Doesn’t Matter

20 August 2010

Is that title seemingly schizophrenic? Yes, but on purpose. I started this post, and set it aside, and then lo and behold, Max Kalehoff at AttentionMax wrote about it in a very similar fashion. So, go read his post, then come back here. Here’s the problem with Twitter follower counts… To some, it does matter. [...]

View Comments [jump to full article]

How To Be On Twitter Without Being On Twitter

16 August 2010

[note: If you're reading this in an RSS reader, the images may not line up well with the text. If you start to get sea sick, pop on out to the full post.] OK, so not the most SEO-friendly headline.  But have you ever been faced with this scenario (either you or someone you know)? [...]

View Comments [jump to full article]

Passionate People: Fred Mullins

10 August 2010

This is the second in my series on passionate people.  You can read the first entry on passionate people where I profile Steve Lewis .  You can also read over there for what this series is all about. Fred Mullins In this post, I’d like to introduce you to Fred Mullins.  On paper, Fred is the [...]

View Comments [jump to full article]

Free and Fast Market Research and Keyword Research

5 August 2010

If you’re looking to spin up quickly on a topic, understand keywords or related (secondary) words to a search term, find out what a person talks about, or want to do some market research, keep reading.  You can use two free tools (Twitter and Wordle) to give you a graphical representation of content, all in [...]

View Comments [jump to full article]